Pages

My Blog List

Showing posts with label 2013 Vintage Reading Challenge. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2013 Vintage Reading Challenge. Show all posts

Thursday, 1 August 2013

Review: The Red House Mystery, A.A. Milne (England)

Title: The Red House Mystery
Author: A.A. Milne
Publication: 1922/UK: Methune
ISBN #: 978-0-09-952127-3
# of pages: ???
Discovered as a free book on my Kobo
Read in e-book format
Also available in paper format, audio CD, illustrated paperback, large print paperback
 
Pretty parlour-maid Audrey Stevens is having a bit of a gossip with her aunt, the cook-housekeeper, about their employer Mark Ablett and his black sheep brother Robert Ablett. None of the household had heard of this brother and now he was due any minute, back from Australia after more than 15 years’ absence. Robert soon arrives and Audrey shows him to the office. A few minutes later, she hears shots which she and the other staff quickly realize came from inside the house. They lock themselves together in a room just as someone starts banging on their door.
 
Help soon arrives in the form of Antony Gillingham. Gillingham got off the train here on a whim and when he learned his friend Bill Beverley was a guest at the Red House, he decided to visit him. He arrives to find a man pounding on a door. The man, Mark’s cousin and secretary-cum-companion, Matthew Cayley, is in a panic because he heard the shots too and can’t get into the office. He is worried about Mark’s safety so the two of them run outside to find another way to access the office. When they finally get into the room, they find Robert dead on the floor and Mark missing.

Shortly afterwards, the house guests – Bill Beverley (young man-around-town), Major Rumbold,  actress Ruth Norris, a painter’s widow Mrs. Calladine, and her daughter Betty – return from their golf game, closely followed by the police. Being curious and between jobs, Gillingham decides to investigate, with Bill acting as his “Dr. Watson”.

This is a classical British manor house mystery! Well-paced with good twists and turns, the book seems written with a light hand: by that, I mean, it has a humorous undertone, as if laughing at itself. The author specifically sets Gillingham and Beverley up as mirrors of Sherlock Holmes and Watson. At first, you wonder if Gillingham has the ability to detect; his jobs have consisted of a bit of this and that but not much of anything. He turns out to an excellent observer of both people and situations. The final scenes, especially Bill’s description, are quite suspenseful and the solution is very creative (although Raymond Chandler apparently felt it was implausible). It was a compelling book to read and I thoroughly enjoyed it. The book ends with an inviting sentence that suggests a sequel but this is the only mystery book the author wrote.     Rating: (^_°)       Intriguing

This is written by THE A.A. Milne, the author more famously known for his Winnie the Pooh books. Why a mystery book? In his dedication, he explained: “To John Vine Milne My Dear Father, Like all really nice people, you have a weakness for detective stories, and feel that there are not enough of them. So, after all that you have done for me, the least that I can do for you is to write you one. Here it is: with more gratitude and affection than I can well put down here.” A.A. M.    I wonder if his father enjoyed it – I certainly did!

Saturday, 8 June 2013

Review: The Hound of the Baskervilles, Arthur Conan Doyle (England)

Title: The Hound of the Baskervilles
Author: Arthur Conan Doyle
Publication: ---
Original Publication: 1901/UK: George Newnes
ISBN #: ---
# of pages: 359
Rediscovered as a free download on my Kobo
Read in e-book format
Also available in paper format, audio CD

A fine silver banded walking stick is left in Sherlock Holmes’ office and when the owner, Dr. James Mortimer, returns to claim it, Holmes and his ever-present sidekick Dr. Watson learn about the curse of the Baskerville family. In the 1640’s, the evil Hugo Baskerville kidnapped a local young woman. She escaped, only to have Hugo chase her through the dangerous moors. When his drunken friends caught up, they found them both dead, and a huge black dog, with blazing eyes and dripping jaws, standing over them.  An account of the event was written down in 1742 by a later heir, also named Hugo, and passed down through the centuries. Now the current heir, Sir Charles Baskerville, has died suddenly and with no apparent foul play, however the paw print of a huge dog is found near the body. The next heir, nephew Henry, is returning from Canada and Mortimer fears he will be the next to die.
Although Holmes becomes intrigued by the mystery, he is not available to go to Devon and sends Watson on his own. Watson has a lot to consider. The Barrymores, long-time family servants, seem in a hurry to leave. Jack Stapleton and his sister Beryl have a complicated relationship, especially apparent when Sir Henry falls in love with Beryl. Could Selden, a dangerous escaped convict hunted by the police, be involved? And who is the mysterious L.L.? With reference to his diary and his recollections, Watson recounts the suspenseful events that lead to the unravelling of the mystery of the Hound.
Arthur Conan Doyle and Agatha Christie were among my earliest murder mystery readings and it was wonderful to re-experience this early entry in the genre.  Despite being written more than one hundred years’ ago, it is still a very readable tale. It was a bit disappointing that Holmes was absent in the first half of the story. Holmes’ and Watson’s discussion about what the walking stick tells them about the owner is one of the few times Holmes’ powers of deduction are demonstrated. He does show his usual flare in uncovering the culprit in the latter part though. Unlike “The Moonstone” written some 30 years earlier (see my review ), the writing here is crisp and to the point. There are not many twists in the storyline but the suspense builds steadily, with the foggy brooding moors always on the horizon, and as the end draws near, you do want to keep reading.     Rating: (^_°)   Intriguing

Notable sentence: Sherlock Holmes to Dr. Watson just before telling him how wrong Watson’s deductions are:  “It may be that you are not yourself luminous, but you are a conductor of light. Some people without possessing genius have a remarkable power of stimulating it.”

Doyle was a Scottish physician best known for the 60 stories he wrote about Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson. He also wrote other short stories, three largely autobiographical novels, and several historical novels. His medical school mentor, Professor Dr. Joseph Bell, was renowned for his powers of observation and became the model for Holmes. Doyle had actually killed off Holmes in an earlier book so that he could concentrate on his spiritualism writings. Sir Henry’s pondering of whether the supernatural interfere in the affairs of mankind reflects Doyle’s own fascination with spiritualism. Doyle's séances to connect with dead relatives is difficult to equate with the creator of a very rational and logical Sherlock Holmes.

Thursday, 14 March 2013

Review: The Moonstone, Wilkie Collins (England)

Title: The Moonstone
Author: Wilkie Collins
Publication: 2006/Project Gutenberg
Original Publication: 1868/Tinsley Brothers, UK
ISBN #: not available
Number of pages:  528
Read in e-book format
Also available in paper format
Discovered many years ago and on the To Be Read list ever since

The action begins with the Storming of Seringapatam, a battle in southern India between the British East India company and the Kingdom of Mysore in 1799. The unnamed narrator is horrified to see his cousin John Herncastle murdering three Indians and he suspects he has stolen the Moonstone, a magnificent yellow diamond, set in the forehead of the Indian god of the moon.

The stone has been around for centuries. After one attempted theft, Vishnu the Preserver appeared to three Brahmins in a dream, cursed anyone who stole it and instructed them to guard it forever. They were successful until the eighteenth century when the Mogul Emperor stole it during a war. The stone then passed through many hands until Herncastle got it, always with three Brahmins hovering in the background, waiting for an opportunity to get it back.

When Herncastle died after a life on the run, the instructions in his will were for his nephew Franklin Blake to give the stone to his niece (Blake’s cousin) Rachel Verinder on her birthday. Three Indian conjurers show up at the English estate around the same time. Blake gives her the stone at her eighteenth birthday party then during the night, it mysteriously vanishes. Since the Indians are still in the area, it is apparent they do not have it but who does? Rachel will not discuss the matter with her family or Sergeant Cuff, the police detective hired by her family to find the thief and the stone.

From here, the mystery is continued through the sequential narratives of several intriguing characters. Gabriel Betteredge, the rather misogynistic house steward to Lady Verinder (Rachel’s mother and Herncastle’s sister) is guided through life by passages from "Robinson Crusoe". He narrates a large part of the story. His narrative is followed by that of Drusilla Clack, Lady Verinder’s god-fearing spinster niece, who pushes her religious tracts on people at every opportunity. The remaining narratives are by family lawyer Mathew Bruff, Franklin Blake himself, Ezra Jennings doctor’s assistant, Mr. Candy the doctor, Sergeant Cliff’s man, a ship’s captain and finally Mr. Murthwaite, a character who keeps popping out throughout the story.

As a mystery buff, I have wanted to read this book for years. It is considered the first English language mystery novel (as opposed to Edgar Allan Poe’s earlier mystery short stories). It was originally serialized in Charles Dickens’ magazine “All the Year Round”.  I am glad I read it, especially since it is the first example of many elements of the modern detective story: bungling local cop, red herrings, false suspects, crime reconstruction and a plot twist, to name a few. But it is a long long book (much like this review). I very much agreed with Gabriel Betteredge at the end of Chapter XXII when he said “if you are as tired of reading this narrative as I am of writing it…” At that point, I was only 35% of the way through the book! Due to the book’s historical significance, it is worth reading and the plot is quite good. I may read Collins’ other best seller “The Woman in White”….but not for awhile.

Have you read any mysteries from the late 1800s or early 1900s? Did they stand the test of time?

Saturday, 9 February 2013

Review: Love Lies Bleeding, Edmund Crispin (England)

Title:                                            Love Lies Bleeding
Author:                                         Edmund Crispin
Date/Place of Publication:             1984/Great Britain: Hamlyn Paperbacks
Original Date/Place of Publication: 1948/Great Britain: Victor Gollancz
ISBN #:                                        0-600-20663-7
# pages:                                       200
Discovered in my own home library
Read in paper format
Also available in e-book format

Dr. Stanford, Headmaster at Castrevenford School, is preoccupied with the school's upcoming Speech Day and the heat. Learning from the local girls' school head mistress, Miss Parry, that something untoward has happened to one of her students at his school only serves to increase his gloomy and unhappy mood. Fortunately, his friend Gervase Fen, Oxford Professor of English and amateur detective, is coming as a last minute substitute to hand out prizes and he will be given the task of ferreting out the truth. Truth-seeking quickly involves multiple murders and a disappearance, all of which are miraculously resolved by the end of the weekend.

This is a fairly traditional English murder mystery, set in the 1940's, with all the boarding school hierarchies, politics and idiosyncrasies on display. Fen is reminiscent of Sherlock Holmes, with his ability to notice minor details and deduce the correct solution out of a multitude of options. Fortunately for the reader, the last 30 pages of the book outline how he did this, through a conversation he has with Dr. Stanford.

The author's Oxford education clearly comes through, in his language as well as his knowledge of prep schools. The reader may wonder if they need to have a dictionary at their side, to deal with "palliating circumstances" and "inchoate daydream(s)", as well as a basic knowledge of Latin (for instance, the first chapter is entitled "Lasciva Puella"). Although this may seem annoying, it helps to establish the time frame of events and set the atmosphere of a 1940's prep school. Interestingly, the young female characters are refreshingly spirited and independent for the era in question.

Even the avid mystery reader will likely find it challenging to determine the final solution but Fen's recap confirms all the clues are there. Worth tackling. I would love to hear your comments on whether you were able to puzzle out the answer.

About the author:

Edmund Crispin is the pseudonym for (Robert) Bruce Montgomery, a British writer who died in 1978 at the age of 56. Not only did he write nine detective stories and two short story collections, he also composed film, concert and church music under his real name. This particular book is dedicated to "The Carr Club". According to David Whittle in "Bruce Montgomery/Edmund Crispin: A Life in Music and Books", this informal society of four friends was inspired by John Dickinson Carr radio plays. They would meet in a public house or rented cottage "...to tell detective stories for which solutions had to be proposed by the members."

Thursday, 27 December 2012

2013 Vintage Mystery Challenge

This challenge is new to me and a bit complicated but will challenge me in new ways. My new Kobo Glo enabled me to download old mysteries for free which will be a great way to learn how to use the e-reader. I have chosen the following Vintage categories:

1. Colorful Crime - "The Red House Mystery" by A.A. Milne (yes, that A.A. Milne) (1922)

4. Leave it to the Professionals - "The Mystery of Orcival" by Emile Gaboriau, featuring Surete detective Monsieur LeCoq (1867)

6. Yankee Doodle Dandy - "The Works of Edgar Allan Poe" (1800s)

7. World Traveler - "The Moonstone" by Wilkie Collins (1868)

14. Scene of the Crime - "The Mystery of a Turkish Bath" by E.M. Gollan (1888)

16. Locked Rooms - "The Mystery of the Yellow Room" by Gaston Leroux

20. Murder is Academic - "Love Lies Bleeding" by Edmund Crispin (1948)

22. Repeat Offenders - "The Hound of the Baskervilles" by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (1901)